Loading, please wait...

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Big Plush Original One Set Of Cuffs CLEAN • $400
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24" Big Plush Original One Set Of Cuffs Clean

400$

Vintage Toymax My Pet Monster Blue No Cuffs • $125
Vintage Toymax My Pet Monster Blue No Cuffs

125$

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original One Cuff Wow! • $299
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24 Inch Big Plush Original One Cuff Wow!

299$

Vintage My Pet Monster Little Meathead 1987 Plush Grail Fast Shipping !!! • $249.99
Vintage My Pet Monster Little Meathead 1987 Plush Grail Fast Shipping !!!

249.99$

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Football 26 AmToy Plush • $99.99
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Football 26" Amtoy Plush

99.99$

Auction
Vtg My Pet Monster 1986 Big Plush Stuffed Toy Original W/ Cuffs • $209.04
Vtg My Pet Monster 1986 Big Plush Stuffed Toy Original W/ Cuffs

209.04$ 27 bids | 1d

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original With Cuffs! • $400
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24 Inch Big Plush Original With Cuffs!

400$

My Pet Monster 2001 Toymax Vintage Plush Collectible Original Box +Tags Unopened • $289.99
My Pet Monster 2001 Toymax Vintage Plush Collectible Original Box +tags Unopened

289.99$

Toymax My Pet Monster 22” Talking Blue Plush Tested 2001 Vintage 1980s • $89.99
Toymax My Pet Monster 22” Talking Blue Plush Tested 2001 Vintage 1980s

89.99$

My Pet Monster 2001 Blue Plush Animal ToyMax Vintage No Cuffs Tested Works • $80
My Pet Monster 2001 Blue Plush Animal Toymax Vintage No Cuffs Tested Works

80$

Auction
Vintage 1986 AmToy My Pet Football Monster 26 Plush With Jersey Helmet Cuffs • $445
Vintage 1986 Amtoy My Pet Football Monster 26" Plush With Jersey, Helmet, Cuffs

445$ 0 bids | 4d

Vintage 1986 My Monster Pet- Rark Plush Hand Puppet Toy Original AmToy • $69.99
Vintage 1986 My Monster Pet- Rark Plush Hand Puppet Toy Original Amtoy

69.99$

Vintage My Pet Monster Plush Toy 24” One Set Of Cuffs • $284.99
Vintage My Pet Monster Plush Toy 24” One Set Of Cuffs

284.99$

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original With Cuffs! • $218.09
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24 Inch Big Plush Original With Cuffs!

218.09$

My Pet Monster Lookalike Monster Plush. Great American Toy Co. 5 Inches Tall • $24.99
My Pet Monster Lookalike Monster Plush. Great American Toy Co. 5 Inches Tall

24.99$

My Pet Monster 2001 Plush Talking Toy W/Handcuffs - Blue Stuffed Animal • $179.99
My Pet Monster 2001 Plush Talking Toy W/handcuffs - Blue Stuffed Animal

179.99$

Auction
Vintage Original My Pet Monster 1986 AmToy 1980s Large Plush Toy Missing 1 Eye • $15.56
Vintage Original My Pet Monster 1986 Amtoy 1980s Large Plush Toy Missing 1 Eye

15.56$ 4 bids | 0d

Vintage AmToy My Pet Monster Football Plush With Shirt 1986 • $62
Vintage Amtoy My Pet Monster Football Plush With Shirt 1986

62$

Vintage 1986 My Pet Football Monster AmToy Plush With Jersey • $150
Vintage 1986 My Pet Football Monster Amtoy Plush With Jersey

150$

Vintage 1986 1987 My Pet Monster Gwonk Yaplet Wogster Zugly Plush Stuffed Animal • $319
Vintage 1986 1987 My Pet Monster Gwonk Yaplet Wogster Zugly Plush Stuffed Animal

319$

Vintage 1986 ~ Org. MY PET FOOTBALL MONSTER ~ AmToy Plush 27 Stuffed Monster • $125
Vintage 1986 ~ Org. My Pet Football Monster ~ Amtoy Plush 27" Stuffed Monster

125$

MY PET MONSTER Embroidered Logo Patch Plush Doll Figure Action Toy 80s Retro • $11
My Pet Monster Embroidered Logo Patch Plush Doll Figure Action Toy 80s Retro

11$

My Pet Monster 25” Plush 1985 American Greetings Amtoy No Handcuffs READ!!!!! • $119.99
My Pet Monster 25” Plush 1985 American Greetings Amtoy No Handcuffs Read!!!!!

119.99$

Auction
Vintage 1980s Original My Pet Monster By AmToy Large 61cm Soft Plush Toy * • $87.11
Vintage 1980s Original My Pet Monster By Amtoy Large 61cm Soft Plush Toy *

87.11$ 0 bids | 7d

Vintage My Pet Monster Amtoy 1986 Large Plush Doll Teddy Without Handcuffs • $56
Vintage My Pet Monster Amtoy 1986 Large Plush Doll Teddy Without Handcuffs

56$

My Pet Monster Animation Cel Vintage Cartoons Production Art 90's Toys Plush I7 • $29.71
My Pet Monster Animation Cel Vintage Cartoons Production Art 90's Toys Plush I7

29.71$

Vintage 1986 Amtoy American Greetings My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush • $78
Vintage 1986 Amtoy American Greetings My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush

78$

Vintage 1986 Amtoy My Pet Football Monster 24 Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Big READ • $278
Vintage 1986 Amtoy My Pet Football Monster 24" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Big Read

278$

My Pet Monster 25” Plush 1985 American Greetings Amtoy No Handcuffs Blue READ • $295
My Pet Monster 25” Plush 1985 American Greetings Amtoy No Handcuffs Blue Read

295$

My Pet Monster Wogster Plush Stuffed Animal Hand Puppet Toy Vintage 1986 Amtoy • $39.99
My Pet Monster Wogster Plush Stuffed Animal Hand Puppet Toy Vintage 1986 Amtoy

39.99$

Vintage Defensors De La Naturaleza Plush OTON Vir Rare 80s My Pet Monster • $299
Vintage Defensors De La Naturaleza Plush Oton Vir Rare 80s My Pet Monster

299$

Auction
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster 24 Inch Big Plush Original Partial Cuffs Amtoy READ • $300
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster 24 Inch Big Plush Original Partial Cuffs Amtoy Read

300$ 0 bids | 1d

VINTAGE My Pet Monster Clip On Plush Toy Amtoy Hugger Topper Hanger Blue 3.1 • $99
Vintage My Pet Monster Clip On Plush Toy Amtoy Hugger Topper Hanger Blue 3.1"

99$

15%
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush With Box Back And Hand Cuffs • $254.96
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24 Inch Big Plush With Box Back And Hand Cuffs

254.96$ 299.95$

Vintage Tara Toys Kuddlee Uglee Plush My Pet Monster Purple • $60
Vintage Tara Toys Kuddlee Uglee Plush My Pet Monster Purple

60$

35%
Vintage Tara Toys Purple Kuddlee Uglee 6 Plush My Pet Monster Leash Orange Hair • $33.07
Vintage Tara Toys Purple Kuddlee Uglee 6" Plush My Pet Monster Leash Orange Hair

33.07$ 50.88$

Vintage 1985 My Pet Monster AmToy 24” Plush Original Good Hands/Feet No Cuffs • $248
Vintage 1985 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24” Plush Original Good Hands/feet No Cuffs

248$

Vintage 1986 My Monster Pet RARK Plush Puppet Toy Great CONDITION • $89.99
Vintage 1986 My Monster Pet Rark Plush Puppet Toy Great Condition

89.99$

My Pet Monster 25” Plush | 1985 American Greetings | Amtoy No Handcuffs • $350
My Pet Monster 25” Plush | 1985 American Greetings | Amtoy No Handcuffs

350$

My Pet Monster 3pc Plush Lot • $350
My Pet Monster 3pc Plush Lot

350$

Auction
NEW 2001 ToyMax MY PET MONSTER Blue Plush Stuffed Animal CUFFS Talk Works! • $181.75
New 2001 Toymax My Pet Monster Blue Plush Stuffed Animal Cuffs Talk Works!

181.75$ 0 bids | 9d

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24 Big Plush 1 Set Cuffs American Greetings • $275
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24" Big Plush 1 Set Cuffs American Greetings

275$

HTF NOS Vintage 1986 MY PET FOOTBALL MOSTER Plush AmToy NEW!! Handcuffs • $1599.99
Htf Nos Vintage 1986 My Pet Football Moster Plush Amtoy New!! Handcuffs

1,599.99$

Vintage 80s My Pet Monster Knock Off Topper Hugger Clip On Plush • $60
Vintage 80s My Pet Monster Knock Off Topper Hugger Clip On Plush

60$

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Rark Plush Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal • $75
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Rark Plush Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal

75$

2001 ToyMax Inc My Pet Monster Plush No Cuffs Voice DOESNT Work • $90
2001 Toymax Inc My Pet Monster Plush No Cuffs Voice Doesnt Work

90$

Auction
Wogster My Monster Pet Vintage 1986 Amtoy Matchbox Soft Toy Plush W/ Cuffs • $62.23
Wogster My Monster Pet Vintage 1986 Amtoy Matchbox Soft Toy Plush W/ Cuffs

62.23$ 1 bids | 2d

MY PET MONSTER Plush W/ Handcuffs & Breakaway Chain AmToy 1986 • $350
My Pet Monster Plush W/ Handcuffs & Breakaway Chain Amtoy 1986

350$

Vintage Rare DEFENSORS De La Naturaleza Plush My Pet Monster Creature Gillman • $450
Vintage Rare Defensors De La Naturaleza Plush My Pet Monster Creature Gillman

450$

Kuddlee Uglee Watch Cover Plush Vintage Tara Toy Corp No Watch My Pet Monster • $30
Kuddlee Uglee Watch Cover Plush Vintage Tara Toy Corp No Watch My Pet Monster

30$

Vintage My Pet Monster American Greetings 1986 Blue Purple Plush Stuffed Animal • $122
Vintage My Pet Monster American Greetings 1986 Blue Purple Plush Stuffed Animal

122$

9%
Rare Grail Toymax 6” Mini My Pet Monster W/ Handcuffs & Skateboard Stuffed Plush • $199.29
Rare Grail Toymax 6” Mini My Pet Monster W/ Handcuffs & Skateboard Stuffed Plush

199.29$ 219$

10%
Vintage My Pet Football Monster 1986 AMTOY RARE Plush Toy Helmet Jersey No Cuffs • $449.99
Vintage My Pet Football Monster 1986 Amtoy Rare Plush Toy Helmet Jersey No Cuffs

449.99$ 499.99$

VTG 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Big Plush Original One Set Of Cuffs 🔥🔥 CLEAN • $399.99
Vtg 1986 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24" Big Plush Original One Set Of Cuffs 🔥🔥 Clean

399.99$

My Pet Monster Rark Plush Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal Vintage 1986 • $94.99
My Pet Monster Rark Plush Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal Vintage 1986

94.99$

Vintage Kuddlee Uglee Plush Monster 6 Cute Small Tara Purple Blue • $11.75
Vintage Kuddlee Uglee Plush Monster 6" Cute Small Tara Purple Blue

11.75$

Vintage 1986 My Pet Football Monster Plush Stuffed Animal Toy (No Helmet) • $120
Vintage 1986 My Pet Football Monster Plush Stuffed Animal Toy (no Helmet)

120$

VTG Kuddlee Uglee Plush 6 My Pet Monster Stuffed Animal Tara Toy Corp • $15
Vtg Kuddlee Uglee Plush 6" My Pet Monster Stuffed Animal Tara Toy Corp

15$

Vintage 1997 SUPER ULTRA RARE Beastly Buddies My Pet Monster Plush - READ!!! • $489.99
Vintage 1997 Super Ultra Rare Beastly Buddies My Pet Monster Plush - Read!!!

489.99$

AmToy My Monster Pet RARK Hand Puppet Plush - VINTAGE 1986 Popular Line Of Toys • $75
Amtoy My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush - Vintage 1986, Popular Line Of Toys

75$

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original No Cuffs. • $350
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24 Inch Big Plush Original No Cuffs.

350$

15%
Vintage My Pet Monster Mini Topper Hugger Clip On Plush Amtoy 1986 Excellent • $84.99
Vintage My Pet Monster Mini Topper Hugger Clip On Plush Amtoy 1986 Excellent

84.99$ 99.99$

My Pet Monster Plush • $199
My Pet Monster Plush

199$

15%
2001 My Pet Monster Breakaway Handcuffs Chain Talking Tested Working Plush • $212.50
2001 My Pet Monster Breakaway Handcuffs Chain Talking Tested Working Plush

212.50$ 250$

My Pet Monster 2001 Plush Stuffed Animal Collectible Toy Vintage Tested & Works • $145
My Pet Monster 2001 Plush Stuffed Animal Collectible Toy Vintage Tested & Works

145$

Vintage My Pet Monster Plush Toy With Handcuffs • $250
Vintage My Pet Monster Plush Toy With Handcuffs

250$

My Pet Football Monster Vintage 1986 AMTOY RARE Plush With Box And Handcuffs • $1798
My Pet Football Monster Vintage 1986 Amtoy Rare Plush With Box And Handcuffs

1,798$

My Pet Monster Wogster Vintage 1986 Stuffed Animal Hand Puppet PLUSH VTG Amtoy • $38
My Pet Monster Wogster Vintage 1986 Stuffed Animal Hand Puppet Plush Vtg Amtoy

38$

Hornby Terror Ted Munch Vintage Horror Plush My Pet Monster Were Beasty Bears 86 • $99.99
Hornby Terror Ted Munch Vintage Horror Plush My Pet Monster Were Beasty Bears 86

99.99$

My Pet Monster Wogster Vintage 1986 Stuffed Animal Hand Puppet AmToy PLUSH VTG • $1499.99
My Pet Monster Wogster Vintage 1986 Stuffed Animal Hand Puppet Amtoy Plush Vtg

1,499.99$

Rare 2001 Toymax 5” My Pet Monster With Handcuffs & Football Stuffed Plush Toy • $200
Rare 2001 Toymax 5” My Pet Monster With Handcuffs & Football Stuffed Plush Toy

200$

AMTOY My Pet Monster Hand Puppet GWONK Plush Toy 1986 Orange Vintage NEW 🔥 • $1499.99
Amtoy My Pet Monster Hand Puppet Gwonk Plush Toy 1986 Orange Vintage New 🔥

1,499.99$

Vintage 6 Tara Toys Plush My Pet Monster Kuddlee Uglee Plush Toy Purple Blue • $20.05
Vintage 6" Tara Toys Plush My Pet Monster Kuddlee Uglee Plush Toy Purple Blue

20.05$

Vintage Kuddlee Uglee Plush Monster 6 Cute Small Tara Purple Blue Still Sealed • $40
Vintage Kuddlee Uglee Plush Monster 6" Cute Small Tara Purple Blue Still Sealed

40$

Vintage 1986 My Pet Football Monster Toy Jersey AmToy Plush • $199.99
Vintage 1986 My Pet Football Monster Toy Jersey Amtoy Plush

199.99$

Vintage Kuddlee Uglee Plush Monster 6 Cute Small Tara Purple Blue W Chain • $34.90
Vintage Kuddlee Uglee Plush Monster 6" Cute Small Tara Purple Blue W Chain

34.90$

Vintage Tara Toys Kuddlee Uglee 6 Plush My Pet Monster Leash Purple Orange Hair • $59.95
Vintage Tara Toys Kuddlee Uglee 6" Plush My Pet Monster Leash Purple Orange Hair

59.95$

Vintage 1986 Tara Toys Purple Kuddlee Uglee Plush My Pet Monster Yellow Hair 80s • $35
Vintage 1986 Tara Toys Purple Kuddlee Uglee Plush My Pet Monster Yellow Hair 80s

35$

Vintage 1986 Amtoy My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush Stuffed Animal Toy • $69.99
Vintage 1986 Amtoy My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

69.99$

⭐RARE 6 Tara Toys Plush My Pet Monster Kuddlee Uglee 1980s Pink Blue • $20
⭐rare 6" Tara Toys Plush My Pet Monster Kuddlee Uglee 1980s Pink Blue

20$

Gwonk Vintage My Pet Monster Hand Puppet Plush Toy 1986 Stuffed Animal MPM • $100
Gwonk Vintage My Pet Monster Hand Puppet Plush Toy 1986 Stuffed Animal Mpm

100$

VINTAGE 1997 ULTRA RARE BEASTLY BUDDIES 'GRUNT' My Pet Monster Plush READ DESCP • $739.95
Vintage 1997 Ultra Rare Beastly Buddies 'grunt' My Pet Monster Plush Read Descp

739.95$

Vintage Kuddlee Uglee Plush Monster 6 Cute Small Tara Purple Blue My Pet Rare • $22
Vintage Kuddlee Uglee Plush Monster 6" Cute Small Tara Purple Blue My Pet Rare

22$

Vintage My Pet Monster Plush Stuffed Animal Hand Cuffs Amtoy 1986 • $450
Vintage My Pet Monster Plush Stuffed Animal Hand Cuffs Amtoy 1986

450$

25%
MONSTER FUR BALL • Plush Novelty Inc Toy 2012 • Madballs My Pet Monster Interest • $11.24
Monster Fur Ball • Plush Novelty Inc Toy 2012 • Madballs My Pet Monster Interest

11.24$ 14.99$

VINTAGE 1985 My Pet Monster Plush Pillow WITH HANDCUFFS VERY Rare! • $299.95
Vintage 1985 My Pet Monster Plush Pillow With Handcuffs Very Rare!

299.95$

My Pet Monster Wogster Plush Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal AmToy VTG 1986 Fun! Read • $92
My Pet Monster Wogster Plush Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal Amtoy Vtg 1986 Fun! Read

92$

VTG Kuddlee Uglee 6 Plush My Pet Monster Purple Chain Yellow Hair Bow Tara Toys • $25
Vtg Kuddlee Uglee 6" Plush My Pet Monster Purple Chain Yellow Hair Bow Tara Toys

25$

Vintage Kuddlee Uglee 6 Plush Toy My Pet Monster Tara Toys 1980's Prop Rare • $23.90
Vintage Kuddlee Uglee 6" Plush Toy My Pet Monster Tara Toys 1980's Prop Rare

23.90$

RARE Vintage 1986 My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush Atmoy Americas Greetings • $105
Rare Vintage 1986 My Monster Pet Rark Hand Puppet Plush Atmoy Americas Greetings

105$

My Pet Monster Wogster Plush Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal AmToy VTG 1986 • $117
My Pet Monster Wogster Plush Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal Amtoy Vtg 1986

117$

6 Tara Toys Plush My Pet Monster Kuddlee Uglee 1980s Pink Blue Stuffed Animal • $35
6" Tara Toys Plush My Pet Monster Kuddlee Uglee 1980s Pink Blue Stuffed Animal

35$

Vintage Kuddlee Uglee Plush Monster 6 Cute Small Rare HTF Tara Purple Blue • $60
Vintage Kuddlee Uglee Plush Monster 6" Cute Small Rare Htf Tara Purple Blue

60$

My Monster Pet Wogster Plush Stuffed Animal Hand Puppet Toy Vintage 1986!!!@ • $60
My Monster Pet Wogster Plush Stuffed Animal Hand Puppet Toy Vintage 1986!!!@

60$

One Eyed Monster 35” Blue Plush Stuffed Animal Unisex For Any Age • $39.75
One Eyed Monster 35” Blue Plush Stuffed Animal Unisex For Any Age

39.75$

One Eyed Monster 35” Blue Valentine's Day Plush Stuffed Animal. New. • $22.99
One Eyed Monster 35” Blue Valentine's Day Plush Stuffed Animal. New.

22.99$

Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster AmToy 24 Inch Big Plush Original With Cuffs. • $400
Vintage 1986 My Pet Monster Amtoy 24 Inch Big Plush Original With Cuffs.

400$

⭐RARE 6 Tara Toys Plush My Pet Monster Kuddlee Uglee 1980s Pink Blue • $29.99
⭐rare 6" Tara Toys Plush My Pet Monster Kuddlee Uglee 1980s Pink Blue

29.99$

Vintage My Pet Monster Complete With Handcuffs Amtoy 1986 Plush Original Large • $186.68
Vintage My Pet Monster Complete With Handcuffs Amtoy 1986 Plush Original Large

186.68$

My Pet Monster Animation Cel Vintage Cartoons Production Art 90's Toys Plush I4 • $37.78
My Pet Monster Animation Cel Vintage Cartoons Production Art 90's Toys Plush I4

37.78$

    • Age Level
    • 17 Years & Up22
    • 12-16 Years19
    • 3-4 Years18
    • 8-11 Years18
    • 4-716
    • 1-2 Years6
    • 12 Months & Under2
    • Size
    • Large (24-36 in)31
    • Small (6-14 in)26
    • Medium (14-24 in)13
    • Mini (Under 6 in)6
    • Featured Refinements
    • My Pet Monster101