Loading, please wait...

Beanie Babies-Mystic The Unicorn • $11.95
Beanie Babies-mystic The Unicorn

11.95$

Rare! Mystic Unicorn Ty Beanie Baby - Tag Errors 1993 1994 - RETIRED • $1100
Rare! Mystic Unicorn Ty Beanie Baby - Tag Errors 1993 1994 - Retired

1,100$

27%
Ty Beanie Baby - MYSTIC The Unicorn (Coarse Mane & Iridescent Horn) • $3.99
Ty Beanie Baby - Mystic The Unicorn (coarse Mane & Iridescent Horn)

3.99$ 5.48$

Ty Beanie Baby “Mystic” The Unicorn Ty 1993-94 Tag Errors Vintage Rare Retired • $299.99
Ty Beanie Baby “mystic” The Unicorn Ty 1993-94 Tag Errors Vintage Rare Retired

299.99$

Iridescent Horn MYSTIC The Unicorn ✨️ MWNMT Near Mint✨️ Original TY Beanie Baby • $8
Iridescent Horn Mystic The Unicorn ✨️ Mwnmt Near Mint✨️ Original Ty Beanie Baby

8$

Auction
Mystic Beanie Baby • $0.99
"mystic" Beanie Baby

0.99$ 0 bids | 5d

Auction
1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn Fine Yarn Mane With Tan Horn 3rd/1st Gen • $50
1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn Fine Yarn Mane With Tan Horn 3rd/1st Gen

50$ 0 bids | 4d

Vtg Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn W/Tag Errors Rare RETIRED 1993 1994 Rope Hair! • $2600
Vtg Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn W/tag Errors Rare Retired 1993 1994 Rope Hair!

2,600$

Auction
TY Beanie Baby - Mystic The Unicorn DOB 05/21/1994 Mint Swing Tag And Tush Tag • $0.99
Ty Beanie Baby - Mystic The Unicorn Dob 05/21/1994 Mint Swing Tag And Tush Tag

0.99$ 0 bids | 3d

TY Beanie Baby MYSTIC The Unicorn 1994 Iridescent Horn Coarse Mane Tail Retired • $3.99
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 1994 Iridescent Horn Coarse Mane Tail Retired

3.99$

Mystic The Unicorn Fine Mane - Rare Beanie Baby - 1st Gen Tush - Sealed With COA • $49.97
Mystic The Unicorn Fine Mane - Rare Beanie Baby - 1st Gen Tush - Sealed With Coa

49.97$

50%
Beanie Baby “Mystic” The Unicorn Ty 1993-94 Tag Errors Vintage Rare Retired • $111
Beanie Baby “mystic” The Unicorn Ty 1993-94 Tag Errors Vintage Rare Retired

111$ 222$

Auction
Ty Mystic The Unicorn Beanie Baby 1993 • $2
Ty Mystic The Unicorn Beanie Baby 1993

2$ 1 bids | 0d

Vintage 1994 TY Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn #4007 • $450
Vintage 1994 Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn #4007

450$

Mystic The Unicorn (Rare) TY Beanie Baby • $1000
Mystic The Unicorn (rare) Ty Beanie Baby

1,000$

1993-1994 Retired Ty Inc. MYSTIC Beanie Baby With ERRORS • $60
1993-1994 Retired Ty Inc. Mystic Beanie Baby With Errors

60$

Auction
TY Original Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 1993 With Tag 8 Inches Long • $7
Ty Original Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 1993 With Tag 8 Inches Long

7$ 0 bids | 0d

1994 Mystic Beanie Baby Unicorn • $0.99
1994 Mystic Beanie Baby Unicorn

0.99$

Ty Beanie Mystic • $6.75
Ty Beanie Mystic

6.75$

Auction
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic 1994 • $0.99
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic 1994

0.99$ 0 bids | 5d

Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - 04007 - W/TAG & PROTECTOR **NEW** • $6.99
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - 04007 - W/tag & Protector **new**

6.99$

TY Beanie Baby - MYSTIC Unicorn (Fine Mane Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - MWNMTs) • $153.89
Ty Beanie Baby - Mystic Unicorn (fine Mane Version) (3rd Gen Hang Tag - Mwnmts)

153.89$

Ty Beanie Original Baby-mystic -dob May 21 1994 Tag In Clear Cover Excellent • $10
Ty Beanie Original Baby-mystic -dob May 21, 1994, Tag In Clear Cover, Excellent

10$

Auction
TY Beanie Baby Mystic • $3
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic

3$ 0 bids | 5d

Rare Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn W/ Errors 1994 Style 4007- Mint Condition • $25.99
Rare Ty Beanie Baby "mystic Unicorn" W/ Errors 1994 Style 4007- Mint Condition

25.99$

28%
Retired 1993 Classic Original Mystic Beanie Baby No Heart Tag • $5.80
Retired 1993 Classic Original Mystic Beanie Baby No Heart Tag

5.80$ 8$

Rare TY Beanie Baby Retired Mystic Iridescent Horn • $9.98
Rare Ty Beanie Baby Retired Mystic Iridescent Horn

9.98$

Auction
Very Rare (2)TY Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn 1993 RETIRED Sealed In Bag • $1.99
Very Rare (2)ty Beanie Babies "mystic The Unicorn" 1993 Retired Sealed In Bag

1.99$ 0 bids | 3d

(Lot Of 2) TY Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn Irridescent Horns Rainbow Mane/tail • $14.99
(lot Of 2) Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn, Irridescent Horns, Rainbow Mane/tail

14.99$

Ty Beanie Babies - Mystic - 3/2 Generations • $44.99
Ty Beanie Babies - Mystic - 3/2 Generations

44.99$

Auction
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn • $10
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn

10$ 0 bids | 3d

25%
Ty Beanie Baby - MYSTIC The Unicorn (Coarse Mane & Iridescent Horn) 4th Gen • $2.99
Ty Beanie Baby - Mystic The Unicorn (coarse Mane & Iridescent Horn) 4th Gen

2.99$ 3.99$

TY Beanie Baby 1993 Mystic The Unicorn Yellow Star Retired Vintage New • $5.69
Ty Beanie Baby 1993 Mystic The Unicorn Yellow Star Retired Vintage New

5.69$

Auction
Ty Beanie Original Baby 1993 Mystic 1995 Pinky 1996 Strut & 1997 Smoochy • $19.99
Ty Beanie Original Baby 1993 Mystic, 1995 Pinky, 1996 Strut & 1997 Smoochy

19.99$ 0 bids | 2d

10%
Vtg Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn W/Tag Errors Rare RETIRED 1993 1994 Rope Hair! • $13.49
Vtg Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn W/tag Errors Rare Retired 1993 1994 Rope Hair!

13.49$ 14.99$

Auction
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn New With Tags Stamp On Inside Or Tush Tag • $25
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn New With Tags Stamp On Inside Or Tush Tag

25$ 0 bids | 4d

TY Beanie Baby Mystic W Tag Retired • $7.50
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic W Tag Retired

7.50$

57%
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn • $3
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn

3$ 7$

Mystic Beanie Baby • $150
Mystic Beanie Baby

150$

Ty Beanie Baby - MYSTIC The Unicorn (Coarse Mane & Iridescent Horn) • $500
Ty Beanie Baby - Mystic The Unicorn (coarse Mane & Iridescent Horn)

500$

Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn Tag Errors Retired 1994 Rope Hair • $100
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn Tag Errors Retired 1994 Rope Hair

100$

Auction
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Style 4007 Brown Horn 1994 MWMT • $0.99
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Style 4007 Brown Horn 1994 Mwmt

0.99$ 0 bids | 5d

14%
Ty Beanie Baby Unicorn - Mystic - 1993 - snow White - Hang Tags Attached - Good • $6
Ty Beanie Baby Unicorn - Mystic - 1993 - snow White - Hang Tags Attached - Good

6$ 7$

10%
RARE TY Beanie Baby 1993 MYSTIC Given Out At 98 WNBA Sparks Vs Mystics No.1485.. • $16.20
Rare Ty Beanie Baby 1993 Mystic Given Out At 98 Wnba Sparks Vs Mystics No.1485..

16.20$ 18$

Auction
Vintage TY Beanie Baby Lot Of 5 - Mystic Stilts Scaly Thomas Bear 2005 Bear • $5
Vintage Ty Beanie Baby Lot Of 5 - Mystic, Stilts, Scaly, Thomas Bear, 2005 Bear

5$ 0 bids | 2d

Beanie Baby “Mystic” The Unicorn Ty 1993-94 Tag Errors Vintage Rare Retired • $9.99
Beanie Baby “mystic” The Unicorn Ty 1993-94 Tag Errors Vintage Rare Retired

9.99$

Ty Beanie Baby Mystic - MWMT (Unicorn Tan Horn Yarn Mane 1994) • $8.89
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic - Mwmt (unicorn Tan Horn Yarn Mane 1994)

8.89$

Auction
Ty Beanie Baby MYSTIC The Unicorn (2009 Version: Pink Hooves) Used No Tag • $0.99
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn (2009 Version: Pink Hooves) Used No Tag

0.99$ 0 bids | 5d

TY Beanie Babies Mystic Iridescent Unicorn • $6.95
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic Iridescent Unicorn

6.95$

RARE Mystic Beanie Baby With Tag Errors • $1999.99
Rare Mystic Beanie Baby With Tag Errors

1,999.99$

TY Original Beanie Baby Mystic 1994 Retired • $350
Ty Original Beanie Baby "mystic" 1994 Retired

350$

Auction
Ty Beanie Baby “Mystic” The Unicorn Ty 1993-94 Tag Errors Vintage Rare Retired • $5.99
Ty Beanie Baby “mystic” The Unicorn Ty 1993-94 Tag Errors Vintage Rare Retired

5.99$ 0 bids | 0d

Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn Rare With Tag Errors! 1993/1994 Oakbrook • $350
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn Rare, With Tag Errors! 1993/1994 Oakbrook

350$

Ty Beanie Baby Babies Rare 3rd 1st Gen Tag Mystic Fine Mane TBB Auth'd MWMT-MQ! • $279.95
Ty Beanie Baby Babies Rare 3rd 1st Gen Tag Mystic Fine Mane Tbb Auth'd Mwmt-mq!

279.95$

Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 🦄🦄 • $4.99
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 🦄🦄

4.99$

 Ty Beanie Buddy Mystic The Unicorn Pony 2001 With Tag • $5
 ty Beanie Buddy Mystic The Unicorn Pony 2001 With Tag

5$

Rare Retired 1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn With Pe Pellets/errors. • $25000
Rare Retired 1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn With Pe Pellets/errors.

25,000$

Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - W/tag Protector • $12.99
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - W/tag Protector

12.99$

60%
Mystic The Unicorn Ty Beanie Baby Unicorn Plush NWT • $6.38
Mystic The Unicorn Ty Beanie Baby Unicorn Plush Nwt

6.38$ 15.95$

Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 🦄🦄 • $3.99
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 🦄🦄

3.99$

40%
Ty Beanie Baby 1993/1994 Mystic With Iridescent Horn And Errors • $4.77
Ty Beanie Baby 1993/1994 Mystic With Iridescent Horn And Errors

4.77$ 7.95$

-g Ty Beanie Baby Babies With Tag Mystic 1993 Unicorn • $4.99
-g Ty Beanie Baby Babies With Tag Mystic 1993 Unicorn

4.99$

Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - Gold Horn - Plus Chops The Lamb • $35
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - Gold Horn - Plus Chops The Lamb

35$

10%
VTG Mystic Unicorn Yarn Mane Rare 1993 Retired Ty Beanie Baby Mint PE Pellets • $6.26
Vtg Mystic Unicorn Yarn Mane Rare 1993 Retired Ty Beanie Baby Mint Pe Pellets

6.26$ 6.95$

TY Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn (brown Horn Coarse Mane) *MWMT* • $6.99
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn (brown Horn, Coarse Mane) *mwmt*

6.99$

TY MYSTIC UNICORN ~ FINE MANE ~ NO HANG TAG 1st Gen Tush Tag Authenticated Dirty • $39.99
Ty Mystic Unicorn ~ Fine Mane ~ No Hang Tag 1st Gen Tush Tag Authenticated Dirty

39.99$

43%
Original Ty Beanie Babies MYSTIC The Unicorn Style 4007 1993/1994 • $3.99
Original Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn Style 4007 1993/1994

3.99$ 7$

Ty Beanie Baby Mystic 2nd Gen Worn Hang Tag 1st Gen Tush Tag • $200
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic 2nd Gen Worn Hang Tag 1st Gen Tush Tag

200$

Rare Retired 1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn With Pe Pellets/errors. • $1000
Rare Retired 1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn With Pe Pellets/errors.

1,000$

TY Beanie Baby : Mystic The Unicorn • $1.50
Ty Beanie Baby : Mystic The Unicorn

1.50$

Retired 1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic • $25
Retired 1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic

25$

Auction
1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn #4007 Iridescent Horn Coarse Mane • $0.99
1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn #4007 Iridescent Horn, Coarse Mane

0.99$ 0 bids | 4d

Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn Rare First Edition With Tan Horn 🦄🦄 • $3.99
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn Rare First Edition With Tan Horn 🦄🦄

3.99$

2 Vtg Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorns. Both Different. One With 1993 Original Tag • $100
2 Vtg Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorns. Both Different. One With 1993 Original Tag

100$

TY Beanie Baby MYSTIC The Unicorn 1994 Iridescent Horn Rainbow Mane Tail Retired • $3.99
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 1994 Iridescent Horn Rainbow Mane Tail Retired

3.99$

45%
Vintage 1993/94 Ty Original Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn With Yarn & 4 Errors Mint • $2.99
Vintage 1993/94 Ty Original Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn With Yarn & 4 Errors Mint

2.99$ 5.48$

RARE Vintage 1993 Ty Beanie Babies Retired Mystic • $3.49
Rare Vintage 1993 Ty Beanie Babies Retired "mystic"

3.49$

Mystic 5/21/94 - Vintage Ty Beanie Baby - Retired • $3.95
Mystic 5/21/94 - Vintage Ty Beanie Baby - Retired

3.95$

Very Rare TY Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn 1993 RETIRED -tag 1994. • $3.95
Very Rare Ty Beanie Babies "mystic The Unicorn" 1993 Retired -tag 1994.

3.95$

Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - 04007 • $8.99
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - 04007

8.99$

29%
TY 1993 Beanie Baby MYSTIC Unicorn Iridescent Horn Rainbow Yarn Hair Tail/Mane • $4.95
Ty 1993 Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn Iridescent Horn Rainbow Yarn Hair Tail/mane

4.95$ 7$

MYSTIC FINE MANE TAN HORN ⭐ 1ST / 1ST GEN MWMT MQ ⭐ Authenticated Ty Beanie Baby • $2950
Mystic Fine Mane Tan Horn ⭐ 1st / 1st Gen Mwmt Mq ⭐ Authenticated Ty Beanie Baby

2,950$

11%
Ty Beanie Baby - MYSTIC The Unicorn (Coarse Mane & Iridescent Horn)(8 Inch) MWMT • $4.90
Ty Beanie Baby - Mystic The Unicorn (coarse Mane & Iridescent Horn)(8 Inch) Mwmt

4.90$ 5.48$

TY Beanie Buddy - Mystic The Unicorn Horse 2001 Floppy Plush Pastel Mane & Tail • $19.99
Ty Beanie Buddy - Mystic The Unicorn Horse 2001 Floppy Plush Pastel Mane & Tail

19.99$

Mystic Brown Horn Course Mane Unicorn #4007 Ty Beanie Baby Mwmts Pvc Pellets! • $3.79
Mystic Brown Horn Course Mane Unicorn #4007 Ty Beanie Baby Mwmts Pvc Pellets!

3.79$

TY Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn 1993 Rope Hair RARE! Tan Horn Unique Errors PVC • $499
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn 1993 Rope Hair Rare! Tan Horn Unique Errors Pvc

499$

Mwt Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn 1993/1994 Tag Error Plush Toy • $2.95
Mwt Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn 1993/1994 Tag Error Plush Toy

2.95$

10%
Retired TY Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn 93-94 Tag Error Rainbow Hair • $1.71
Retired Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn ,93-94 Tag Error, Rainbow Hair

1.71$ 1.90$

TY Beanie Baby - MYSTIC The Unicorn 3rd Gen Hanging Tag 1st Gen Tush Tag • $8
Ty Beanie Baby - Mystic The Unicorn 3rd Gen Hanging Tag 1st Gen Tush Tag

8$

TY Beanie Baby Mystic Two • $4.50
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Two

4.50$

Ty Beanie Uk Mystic Fine Mane 2nd/1st Gen. Mwmt Mq. Tbb Authenticated • $695
Ty Beanie Uk Mystic Fine Mane 2nd/1st Gen. Mwmt Mq. Tbb Authenticated

695$

Auction
MYSTIC Beanie Baby 1993 DOB 05/21/1994 Swing And Tush Tags. • $4
Mystic Beanie Baby 1993 Dob 05/21/1994 Swing And Tush Tags.

4$ 0 bids | 2d

Ty Beanie Baby Family Of 7 - Swoops Smoochy Goochy Mystic Snort Peace Scorch • $35
Ty Beanie Baby Family Of 7 - Swoops Smoochy Goochy Mystic Snort Peace Scorch

35$

Ty Beanie Baby Pair Of Mystic The Unicorn W/ Different Color Horns Tag Errors • $475
Ty Beanie Baby Pair Of Mystic The Unicorn W/ Different Color "horns" Tag Errors

475$

TY Beanie Babies 1994 And 1993 Mystic Style 4007 • $10
Ty Beanie Babies 1994 And 1993 Mystic Style 4007

10$

Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn (Coarse Mane & Iridescent Horn) • $5
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn (coarse Mane & Iridescent Horn)

5$

Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 5/21/94 White With Blue Eyes NEW WITH TAGS • $5
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 5/21/94 White With Blue Eyes New With Tags

5$

Ty Beanie Baby Babies Rare 1st Gen Tush Tag Mystic Fine Mane • $34.99
Ty Beanie Baby Babies Rare 1st Gen Tush Tag Mystic Fine Mane

34.99$

RARE Retired TY Beanie Baby Mystic With Tag ERRORS • $300
Rare Retired Ty Beanie Baby, Mystic With Tag Errors

300$

Vintage TY Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn Retired Rare Numbered • $150
Vintage Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn Retired Rare Numbered

150$

    • Age Level
    • 3-4 Years1238
    • 17 Years & Up748
    • 8-11 Years703
    • 12-16 Years605
    • 4-7599
    • 1-2 Years283
    • 12 Months & Under250
    • Character Family
    • Care Bears9
    • Disney Princess3
    • Blue's Clues1
    • Looney Tunes1
    • SpongeBob SquarePants1
    • Featured Refinements
    • Mystic Beanie Baby3084
    • Bear Beanie Baby39
    • Peace Beanie Baby7
    • Valentino Beanie Baby5
    • Beanie Boo4
    • Princess Diana Beanie Baby2
    • Curly Beanie Baby1
    • Erin Beanie Baby1
    • Osito Beanie Baby1
    • Ty Princess Beanie Baby1
    • Valentina Beanie Baby1
    • Brand
    • Ty3271